Pearl Jam: VS Album Review
When Pearl Jam released their sophomore album Vs. on October 19, 1993, the band faced the enormous challenge of following up Ten - a debut so commercially massive and culturally seismic that it helped define the grunge era. Rather than bow to commercial expectations, Pearl Jam responded with a rawer, more aggressive, and defiantly unpolished record that captured the tension, energy, and evolution of a band determined to control its own destiny. Vs. not only avoided the sophomore slump - it solidified Pearl Jam’s status as one of the most vital and uncompromising rock bands of the 1990’s.
Vs. is a sonically muscular and diverse album that sees Pearl Jam stretching their musical identity far beyond the polished arena-rock sheen of Ten. The guitars - handled by Stone Gossard and Mike McCready - are sharper, more jagged, and less processed. Tracks like “Go” and “Animal” bristle with punkish urgency, driven by churning riffs and explosive drumming from Dave Abbruzzese, whose precise yet ferocious style elevated the band’s rhythm section significantly.
The album’s tonal diversity is one of its strengths. Songs like “Dissident” and “Rearviewmirror” are built on layered, soaring guitar work that balances melody and catharsis, while “Elderly Woman Behind the Counter in a Small Town” strips back the distortion for an acoustic, folk-rock ballad that reveals the band’s melodic sensibilities and emotional nuance.
Jeff Ament's bass lines are more prominent and adventurous compared to Ten, notably on tracks like “Rats”, where his funky, walking bass forms the backbone of the song’s groove. Meanwhile, Eddie Vedder’s vocals are less reverb-drenched and more direct - whether growling with frustration in “Leash” or delivering plaintive introspection on “Indifference”. His lyrical focus shifted, too, moving from personal turmoil to broader themes of social alienation, control, freedom, and resistance.
Sonically, Vs. feels less like a product of the studio and more like a band playing live in a room, with producer Brendan O’Brien encouraging a raw, immediate sound that stripped away much of the polish that had characterized Ten. The result is an album that breathes and pulses with organic energy.
Where Ten embraced soaring, anthemic rock structures, Vs. was deliberately more confrontational and less commercial - a bold move for a band under immense pressure to replicate their debut’s success. The songwriting is bolder, more experimental, and less concerned with radio-friendliness.
Pearl Jam infused Vs. with a thematic defiance, both lyrically and musically. Songs like “W.M.A.” (short for White Male American) take on issues of racial profiling with tribal percussion and a hypnotic groove, departing from traditional song structures. “Leash” is a rallying cry against authority and societal conformity, with Vedder shouting, “Drop the leash, drop the leash / Get outta my fuckin’ face!” - an emblem of the band's increasing resistance to being pigeonholed or commodified.
What made Vs. stand out at the time - especially in the peak of early '90s alternative rock - was Pearl Jam’s refusal to play into grunge clichés. They blended punk, hard rock, folk, funk, and blues into a cohesive, dynamic whole, paving the way for their later stylistic experiments and solidifying a sound that was unmistakably their own.
The creation of Vs. was marked by significant internal and external pressures. Riding the colossal success of Ten (which had sold millions worldwide), the band was exhausted and wary of being overexposed or manipulated by the media and record industry. Their growing distrust of fame and commercial machinery seeped into both the music and the recording environment.
Recorded primarily at The Site, a remote studio in Nicasio, California, under producer Brendan O’Brien, the sessions were intense and sometimes fractious. Eddie Vedder, in particular, felt the weight of expectations and struggled with balancing the pressures of stardom with his desire to maintain artistic integrity. He frequently clashed with both industry executives and his own bandmates, sometimes isolating himself during the recording process to focus on lyrics and vocals away from distractions.
Drummer Dave Abbruzzese, who had joined Pearl Jam after the recording of Ten, also introduced a new dynamic. His hard-hitting style injected energy into the sessions, but he didn’t always see eye to eye with Vedder, adding to an atmosphere of creative tension. Yet, ironically, these struggles infused Vs. with the urgency and grit that make it so compelling.
Upon release, Vs. broke multiple records. It debuted at #1 on the Billboard 200, selling an unprecedented 950,000 copies in its first five days - a record for first-week sales at the time. It remained at the top of the charts for five consecutive weeks, a testament to the band’s enormous and devoted fanbase despite their anti-mainstream stance.
The album produced several hit singles, including:
Go
Daughter (which became one of the band’s most enduring live staples)
Animal
Dissident
Critically, Vs. was praised for its raw sound, matured songwriting, and willingness to diverge from the template of its predecessor. The album is often cited as a pivotal moment where Pearl Jam took control of their artistic narrative, rejecting fame on their own terms.
To date, Vs. has sold an estimated over 7 million copies in the United States (7× Platinum, RIAA certified) and around 12 million copies worldwide. Its reputation has only grown over time, often lauded as one of the band’s most cohesive and powerful statements, and a defining work of 1990s alternative rock.
Vs. is not merely the sound of a band following up a hit record - it’s the sound of a band fighting for its soul. With muscular musicality, fearless originality, and a palpable sense of internal and external struggle, Pearl Jam crafted an album that defied expectations and established their long-term artistic identity. It remains a visceral, passionate, and essential listen, over three decades later.
Click Here to buy an original copy of Pearl Jam's VS on Vinyl, Cassette or CD
